Saturday, November 28, 2015

Do Report Card Narratives Lead to Positive Change?

It's that wonderful (aka exhausting) time of year!

Trimester report card narratives were due to my administrator on Tuesday. My very quiet disclaimer: Self Science, the class I teach for all students in 5th -8th grade, does not have its own space on the report card, so I don't actually have to/get to write them.  In fact, I am very fortunate that I don't deal with grades in my classes. I spend a lot of time inviting students in reflective conversations on shared google docs where we share thoughts and observations.  How could I even begin to "grade" social and emotional skills anyway?

Asking questions about why and how we do it: 

Before I begin, let me emphasize that I am questioning the "system", not criticizing the work of hard working teachers.
My awesome, and exhausted after writing way too many narratives colleagues ask for input, so I  have the opportunity to edit, and sometimes reframe comments that need a bit of clarity.  Despite the fact that I work in a school where teachers are strengths-oriented and skilled at observation, I still wonder if narratives could be more productive and useful. Does the incredible investment of time pay off? Do parents actually find the paragraphs and paragraphs written about their middle schoolers helpful? Do the narratives lead to positive change?

Here's another main concern:  So much of what we write seems so subjective, more about "who" we think a kid is, instead of "what" they have done during the trimester.

What would happen if we made a more concerted attempt to avoid judgment oriented phrases such as:  Nicole is a conscientious and generous student..  and tried something more "action" specific: Nicole works diligently in class and often goes out of her way to help peers when they are struggling to understand.

Perhaps the key is in student voice: 

What if we ask students for their reflections on their performance before writing their narratives, so we can compare their view of their effort and improvement with our own perception? What if a student's reflection actually landed on the report card? Wouldn't it be a rich discussion for parents to compare and contrast the student's impression with the teacher's report? What if report cards included goals and action items co-created by students and teachers?

I'd love to hear from you..
How do you ensure that your narratives lead to positive change?


44 comments:

Fabiana Casella said...

Narratives definitely help and encourage!
What also has always worked for me (I teach English as a Foreign Lang in my country Argentina but also taught Spanish and ESL for the public school system in North Carolina) is weekly or monthly motivational notes,(sometimes the notes say I´m a bit worried about xx´s attitude or last grades etc etc, I believe hi-her potential will help to overcome etc etc) Does this make sense to you? Definitely having talks/conversation with Ss, notes to parents but indirectly "directed" to their children work very well(agendas which in my school here go out every Friday).
Just hoping I´ve answered part of your question.
Warm greetings from Buenos Aires!
Fabiana Casella

Joan Young (aka Mancini) said...

Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts! Make total sense to me.More frequent conversation definitely makes the communication more growth oriented and helpful I think. Thanks again!

Unknown said...

So pleasant to read such posts. I just realize that there are teachers who try their best to give knowledge and help kids to develop. Parents could only dream about such mentor for their kid. I believe that specialists, who try to practice such tips are able to create an awesome atmosphere in the classroom and their students are happier and more successful. I remember the time when we had to search for the best essay writer in Britain because we just cannot inspire our child to learn and to express ideas. It is not that easy as learning some rule or making sum. It is about desire to express thoughts.

Unknown said...

You have done an incredible job, you were able to collect in one article a non-veritable number of facts and details. I may say that online writers for a long period of time helped me and I even wrote my own article about it. Anyway, thanks a lot for posting it.

Unknown said...

A very good article, especially useful for those who have not very good skills in this. The main thing is always to remember the main points and you will achieve the desired result. I used this before essay writing service, as an example. They did excellent work that helped me in my studies, and also taught me to write such things without difficulties.

Unknown said...

Learning deprived me of the opportunity to spend the time to relatives, go out with a dog and play video games with friends. No, I'm not complaining, but I'm actually looking for options to simplify my life, at least not for long and it seems custom paper services can help me. I hope it won't be very expensive, although what's the matter, I'm ready to do anything but write essays, coursework and other written boring.

Anonymous said...

Need a little more guidance on how to write a narrative essay ? Follow our step-by-step mini-manual, and by the end, you will feel like a real writer who has just completed the first book.

Mihail337 said...

Academic writing refers to a style of expression that researchers use to define the intellectual boundaries of their disciplines and their specific areas of expertise. https://writingcollegeessays.org/personal-statement-example/ is all about academic writing.

rhetorical analysis ideas said...

Hello everybody! My name is Patrik and i am 26 years old girl from Europe. But anyway i still work at english writing service SpeedyPaper. I really love my work and i know that this is one of the best writing services in internet. If you need some help with essay or other study work then just join our site and SpeedyPaper will help you.

Unknown said...

I can recommend an excellent writing service https://rocketpaper.net/satire-essay

Joson Froster said...

If you feel that you need help when it comes to writing sociology papers then we could help you. Here at Erik Erikson psychosocial theory we have some of the best professional writers that are ready and waiting to make your academic writing very much easier. In fact, we can take all the stress and hard work out of writing, so that you are free to get on with whatever else you choose to do

You may decide to try and buy a sociology research paper online somewhere but you need to be aware of some things. Those sites will offer sociology papers for sale but they have been sold to hundreds of other people. You have no idea where those papers came from and who wrote them. You do not know the academic level of the writer and chances are you will have to spend time tweeking the paper to your professor’s specifications. For that kind of hassle you might as well just write the paper yourself.

TopEssayServices said...

Thank you very much for sharing this post. Carry on it. I know some place where a lot of essays – . If u have no writing skills then u can just use this service –https://www.topessayservices.com/

Scarlet Klark said...

Academic writing is clear, concise, focussed, structured and backed up by evidence. Its purpose is to aid the reader’s understanding.
It has a formal tone and style, but it is not complex and does not require the use of long sentences and complicated vocabulary.
Each subject discipline will have certain writing conventions, vocabulary and types of discourse that you will become familiar with over the course of your degree. However, there are some general characteristics of academic writing that are relevant across all disciplines.
Read more about academic writing at Personal Statement Example

Toni Myran said...

With assignments piling up during the academic right throughout the year it makes sense to start looking for the answer to that question Who can do my homework for me? as soon as possible. As the saying goes, the best time was yesterday, the second best time is now! So once you’ve decided to take the plunge and go looking for some professional academic help with your homework there are quite a few things you should know before you choose the service you need.

If you are fed up with so many assignments or you have tried to determine what to write, but you cannot find anything, then you do not need to worry. A student needs to have free time to have fun and relax. The homework online services for sale is an ideal solution for any student who is overwhelmed or cannot find time for his or her assignments. Expert writers STATISTICS ONLINE ASSISTANCE write assignments excellently in order to help students to succeed in their careers. The service is offered at an affordable price and it is available whenever you need it.

Vladlen Ariston said...

So why choose us when looking for professional assistance on writing successful medical school essays ? The answer is obvious. We are the team that conceals no information from our customers. You are always welcome to browse our reviews section to discover how satisfied our customers are. We are very proud of our good name and reputation and we are happy to see every single positive response and evaluation of our best practices. From the number of positive responses on our website you may see that we excel ourselves to meet the highest standards you require and we are extremely good at that.

The fact that you are on cosmetic surgery research paper outline right now means you have found a company of professional essay writers you can trust. A reputable team of highly educated and vastly experienced essayists, we will make sure that the piece of writing you purchase from us is the best one you can imagine. The writers from our agency have the necessary education to give you a very good argumentative essay on health care or an original research paper on health care because health care issues are among the most prioritized directions of our business.

Puremelda said...

All of our custom term paper writing service will always be 100% unique and authentic work composed by an essayist on our writing team as plagiarism is a crucial area when it comes to seeking custom dissertation writing services in our firm.

meldaresearch said...

Your search for Pre Written Research Paper ends here. Welcome to the home of best essay writers who are qualified in diverse fields. Our Pre Written Essays for Sale is proof that we are right near you. It is easy, place your order and get original plagiarism free assignments. What’s more, we keep everything confidential.

MyAssignmentHelp said...

Thank you for sharing this informative post.MyAssignmenthelp.co.uk is giving english dissertation writing help to students.we are already trusted by thousands of students who struggle to write their academic papers and also by those students who simply want english dissertation Help to save their time and make life easy.

Florahmelda said...

Our Creative Essay Writing Service is accessible online via a majority of mobile devices to bring most Affordable Creative Essay Papers close to you. Students can access Online Creative Essay For Sale from any location if they have a pertinent mobile device.

Clipping Path said...



Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic blog post.

Ideal Assignment Help said...

Computer Science Assignment Help is one among the foremost wanted services that we provide to students studying computer sciences in Australia. Our team of experts have well qualified and equipped to supply assistance in any given computer-oriented language and operating systems. With years of industry experience and practical exposures, our subject material experts can provide a mistake free solution to all or any your problems and doing assignments will become a cakewalk.

belly boys said...

Kareerkonncect is a leading software training institute providing Software Training, Project Guidance, IT consulting and Technology Workshops. Using our enhanced global software training delivery methodology, innovative software training approach and industry expertise, we provide high-value corporate training services that enable our clients to enhance business performance, accelerate time-to-market, increase productivity and improve customer service. More Info- OPT and CPT jobs

Olivia Crew said...

Excellent erudition Providing by your Article, thank you for taking the time to share with us such a nice article. Amazing insight you have on this, it's nice to find a website that details so much information about different artists. Kindly visit the LiveWebTutors website we providing the best online assignment help services in Australia.

For More Info: Law Assignment Help

Max Willor said...

Thank you for this information, it is very useful for all. Get the best My Assignment Help Services at the cheapest price. Myassignmenthelpau provides the best organizational culture Assignment help Australia. Therefore, to avail of our assignment help offering no plagiarism, Free Turnitin, Partial Payment, Unlimited Revisions, etc. you'll contact our team of highly professional, experienced, Ph.D. experts to avail the discounted services!

Best Travel Portal Development said...

Make your travel portal more user-friendly by using flight API among the travelers. Team India Web design offers the best and error-free Flight API Integration to the travel agents at the best price.

belly sons said...

Global Interscope is the best swimming pools designing in Hyderabad where the you can get all the facilities to improve better.

Swimming pool equipment in hyderabad, Execution, Equipment Supplies, Services and Lifestyle Products.

MikeVessels said...

Travelportalonline is a leading travel portal development company providing airline reservation system at low cost.

Robert John said...

I was just searching for this information for a while. After 6 hours of continuous search, at last, I got it in your site. Thanks a lot

Check this - Error 0x000003eb

Veronica Kate said...

I agree with the facts you stated above. You have a beautiful flow with words. For students who are struggling to write their assignments on their own, I suggest they choose the APA Referencing Generator service of LiveWebTutors. It is a perfect and affordable platform that helps you to achieve top grades in your academic activities.

Retail Cloud said...

Retail cloud is offering Enterprise Retail management on Cloud that supports the entire Retail Business. Get all traditional and Digital Commerce related services under one roof.
https://retailclouds.com/

Anonymous said...

Check out the high quality Free Guest Post site. grow your business by ranking on top on organic search.

ozpaperhelp said...

Thank you so much for providing such information
Hi, you are searching for the best assignment help services.Ozpaperhelp.com is the great platform where you can get the best information services.
Buy Dissertation Assignment Help
Dissertation Help Service London
Dissertation Help Online
Dissertation Proposal Help
Dissertation Assistance Service
Plagiarism Free Dissertation Help
Dissertation Writing
Academic Dissertation Help
Perfect Dissertation Layout
Intervention of Problematic Drug Use
Information Systems in Organization
Database Analysis and Design Assignment
Higher National Diploma in Business
Impact of Globalization on McDonald’s Success
Reflection Of My Placement
Social Networks In Business
Nursing Care Plan
Practical placement task
HND Diploma in Digital Marketing
HND Diploma in Entrepreneurship
English Dissertation Help
Law Dissertation Help

Brooklyn Smith said...

If your university or college teacher gives you an assignment or project which is difficult to solve, then you try out GoAssignmentHelp.com services. We offer superior quality college assignment help, with the team of highly qualified and skilled professionals. GoAssignmentHelp.com introduces you to best assignment writer’s academicians in every field to fulfil your every environmental economics assignment help, essay, project, research, and dissertation need. Our experts strive to reach students studying in distant areas and help them accomplish complex tasks and achieve appreciative grades. Feel free to browse our website and get in touch with our live support as well for further buy assignment online queries. So go ahead register and let us do the rest for you.

Anna said...

You can enlarge the list of colleges you are applying to by using DigitalEssay.net This service can help you out with any essay u need.

lordwilliam said...

assignment help services: You can now buy you assignment online, made by expert writers with professional experience in the field! Just visit assignment help services.

John Wick said...

One of the best Top Cosmetics brand "colour cosmetics" Providing high quality products in the lowest prices in the market.

diamond glow elegant whitening beauty milk
nutriclair lightening glycerin
neutrlab website
camille rose oud rich infusion hair oil
hair chemist coconut oil serum
daggett and ramsdell eye fade cream
dh7 lightening cream

John Wick said...

tgin miracle repair serum
hollywood curl cold wave solution kit-hollywood perm kit
pure glow soap
kinky curly seriously smooth prep & protect
tgin miracle repair anti breakage serum
queen helene placenta hot oil treatment
jane carter incredible curls cream
extreme glow strong lightening serum

John Wick said...

pure white cosmetic gold glowing
tgin miracle repair anti-breakage serum
magic wave curved palm brush
carotein serum
cocoa glow supreme brightening milk reviews
nutriclair glycerine
neutrogena oil balancing daily exfoliator
radiant glow solutions
neutrlab hair products

kinglalisah said...

Excellent wording shared your all blogs and, I found it while surfing around on Google and trust me your website blogs rank on top 3 in SERP. Content of this page is unique as well as well researched, I have never seen like this information about this topic. I have reading many blogs. Thank you for sharing great information to us, You are master on this field. Bless you guys. paraphrasing services - assignment help in australia - assignment help sydney - assignment help in melbourne

Smith said...

Thanks for excellent blog.I'm happy to find useful blog share in my friends. Private Tutor Boca Raton THANK YOU

شركة المثالى said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
永远祝福 said...

Dispensary care is Weed what many people lack in the interior areas of the world. Weed, can help you recover shortly. marijuana. people face a lot of health issues everyday without solution. Weed However, marijuana has always been a perfect remedy for ill health. Nevertheless, cocaine may also help.

Shira said...

We Global Assignment Expert have a team of thousands of top experts. They are from different backgrounds and subjects. We have hired only the premium and most experienced academic writers who can provide you with assignment writing help services in almost all the subjects. Their immense knowledge and experience make them the best in the industry. Our teams are available in the whole USA, so you don’t need to worry about your location.

jackowen said...

I am looking for the sheer information in the respective business domain. But I hardly find any ideal destination even though making dozens effort. But, right now I am thanksgiving to GOD to pass the related information of your subject. Now, I believe on the live update of Assignment Help service to optimize our knowledge. Scroll down our website to know more information.